The Poison Candy Murders | Yore Town Podcast Ep. 86

This Yore Town Podcast episode delves into the infamous Poison Candy Murders of 1898 in Dover, Delaware, exploring themes of love, betrayal, and obsession. The tale centers around Mary Elizabeth Pennington, who, after receiving a box of poisoned chocolates, tragically succumbs to arsenic poisoning. The narrative unfolds with the backstory of her husband, John Dunning, and his affair with Cordelia Botkin, leading to a sensational trial that captivated the nation. The discussion reflects on the impact of this case on legal proceedings and societal views on love and revenge.

Episode Key Points

The Poison Candy Murders highlight the dark side of love and obsession.

Cordelia Botkin's actions were driven by jealousy and betrayal.

The case introduced new legal challenges regarding interstate crime.

The trial of Cordelia Botkin was sensational and widely publicized.

The use of the postal service as a weapon was unprecedented.

The tragedy left lasting scars on the Pennington family.

John Dunning's downfall was a result of his own choices.

The case serves as a cautionary tale about trust and betrayal.

Arsenic, a tasteless poison, can be deadly without detection.

The story reflects societal attitudes towards women and crime in the 1890s.

Check out all the podcast on the Beard Laws Studio: https://beardlawsstudio.com

Check out the interactive map at https://yoretown.com

Yore Town Podcast is a podcast that features your towns dark, wild, unbelievable past that has you thinking no way that really happened here. Matt and Megh dust off the books, hit the streets and an occasional nursing home to unveil Yore Town's past. From small towns to where we live to big cities before they were what they are today. This is Yore Town, Yore Stories

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.