-
サマリー
あらすじ・解説
In this episode, we trace the origins of the modern pedigree dog, exploring how today’s breeds were shaped not just by biology, but by social class, fashion, blood sports, and emerging Victorian ideas about heredity. Drawing on Michael Brandow’s A Matter of Breeding and Michael Worboys’ historical analysis of breed invention in Britain, we examine how breeding moved from practical function to aesthetic ideal, and how the development of dog shows and breed clubs entrenched narrow definitions of what a dog should be. From dished bulldog faces to designer Labs, this episode explores the cost of perfection.Key topics* From function to form: how working dogs became breed stereotypes* Dog shows, conformation, and the creation of the breed standard* Victorian science, social class, and early genetics* Fashion, celebrity, and cultural trends in breed popularity* The health and welfare consequences of selective breeding* The rise of the commercial dog industryLong-read articleBook overviewThis episode draws on two complementary sources:* Michael Brandow’s A Matter of Breeding is a polemical critique of the modern dog fancy, blending personal narrative with social history. * Michael Worboys’ essay The Invention of the Modern Dog Breed and Blood in Victorian Britain offers a more academic analysis of how 19th-century British culture—and emerging ideas of heredity and animal classification—produced the concept of the pedigree breed.Together, they tell a story of transformation: from dogs as functional animals with diverse forms and roles, to dogs as aesthetic commodities, shaped to meet the social, scientific, and cultural ideals of the humans who breed, own, and display them.From function to fashion: the artificiality of breedBrandow’s critique opens with Bob, a bulldog whose anatomy illustrates how far selective breeding has strayed from canine function. His “super-sized skull,” “collapsed snout,” and immobile gait embody the disconnection between what dogs are shaped to look like and what they can actually do. This isn’t evolutionary adaptation—it’s human projection, exaggerated over generations.Breeds like the Jack Russell, Basenji, and Shiba Inu rise and fall in popularity not due to function, but because they match a cultural moment. Sleek and minimal, exotic and primitive, youthful and cheeky—dogs become lifestyle symbols, their popularity driven by advertising campaigns and celebrity endorsements rather than suitability to task or temperament.Inventing breeds: how Victorian Britain redefined the dogWorboys describes how, prior to the 1860s, dogs were classified loosely as “types,” “sorts,” or “varieties.” A retriever was something that retrieved. A spaniel was named for its region or behaviour. Variation within these groups was accepted. Breed, in the modern sense—fixed, repeatable, with a written standard—didn’t yet exist.That changed with the rise of livestock breeding models, applied first to cattle and sheep, and then to dogs. Breed became a system for controlling bloodlines. Stud books, conformation shows, and detailed descriptions of the “ideal dog” emerged. What mattered now was not what a dog could do, but how closely it matched the standard.Dog shows and the pursuit of perfectionThe Bulldog Club (founded 1875) exemplified this shift. It defined not just what a bulldog should look like, but how it must look—"broken noses," "dished faces," "broken backs." These standards were enforced through the show ring, with judges trained to reward conformity. Some features were so extreme that puppies underwent painful modifications to better match the standard.John Henry Walsh (“Stonehenge”) hoped to unify breed definitions nationally through his publications. His goal was consistency. But critics feared that rigid definitions would prioritise appearance over health, leading to exaggerated, fragile animals—an early warning still relevant today.Class, fashion, and the shaping of tasteThe Victorian elite used dogs as markers of social distinction. Breed ownership signalled wealth, status, and masculinity. The English bulldog became a mascot for elite institutions. The Labrador retriever became synonymous with landed gentry and private estates.The Duke of Windsor’s fondness for yellow Labs helped make the colour fashionable. In modern advertising, breed choice becomes an extension of identity—urban chic, rugged independence, old-money tradition. As Brandow notes, “tastes in dogs are in a constant state of flux.” But that flux reflects the culture, not the dog.Victorian science and breeding ideologyWorboys highlights the influence of scientific and pseudo-scientific ideas on dog breeding. Craniology linked skull shape to temperament. Telegony—the idea that a female dog’s first mate permanently influenced all future offspring—shaped mating decisions and female dog value. Even attempts at “rational breeding,” like Everett Millais’s ...