Send us a text

What happens when a successful gym reaches a breaking point? In this revealing conversation, former CrossFit gym owner Tyler Sullivan shares his 13-year entrepreneurial journey from startup struggles through exponential growth to a successful business exit.

Tyler takes us back to 2013 when his Milwaukee-based gym was thriving financially but operationally overwhelming. Facing burnout and considering closure, he instead made a pivotal decision to hire his first employee—someone who could handle everything he didn't want to do but needed to be done. This single choice transformed his business and personal life, creating space for strategic thinking and family time.

The conversation explores how systematizing a fitness business creates freedom rather than constraint. With his brother's help, Tyler implemented principles from the book "Traction," developing operational structures that allowed the gym to scale. We hear candidly about the marketing challenges faced by most studio owners, with Tyler revealing how establishing solid sales processes before scaling advertising prevented wasted spending and staff frustration.

Most powerfully, Tyler discusses his decision to sell the business in 2023. After rebuilding post-pandemic, he confronted the reality that his passion had diminished: "I started to not like things more than I liked things, and it's not fair to the customer or employees to continue if I'm not going to enjoy it." His successful exit to his head coach demonstrates how building strong systems creates both business value and personal freedom.

Are you trapped in the daily operations of your studio? Or considering whether to expand or exit? Tyler's journey offers invaluable insights for fitness entrepreneurs at every stage. Connect with him on Instagram @BCF_Tyler or email tyler@badgercrossfit.com for more wisdom from someone who's navigated the full entrepreneurial cycle.

Support the show

Subscribe to our Newsletter: https://creatitive.com/fit-to-grit-cast/